Akademikerfinanz Mannheim DE|EN|فا Book an appointment
Health insurance

Public or private? Two equal systems, one decision for life

Reza Abadi

Almost every well-paid professional asks me this question. There are more myths about it than about any other insurance topic. Here are the facts, and at the end our honest recommendation.

Germany has two fully fledged health insurance systems side by side. If you earn more than €77,400 a year as an employee, are self-employed or a civil servant, you can choose. This page shows how they differ, what they cost and why premiums rise.

The key points in 30 seconds
  • Both systems are strictly regulated and designed as equals. Both have the task of providing care for insured people in Germany and keeping costs under control.
  • Private premiums do not rise because you get older. That is what the ageing reserve is for. They rise, as in public insurance, because medicine gets more expensive: from 2005 to 2025 by 3.1 % a year on average, public by 4.0 %.
  • Private gives you more benefits, guaranteed by contract. Public insurance is very good basic care, private adds senior consultants, fast specialist appointments and new methods. Neither system has a maximum sum.
  • Private is usually a decision for life. So do not only calculate for today, but also for retirement.

Two systems, one task

People often act as if public insurance were the “real” one and private a kind of luxury. That is not true. Both systems are highly regulated, both are supervised by the state, and since 2009 everyone in Germany must be insured in one of them. They differ not in their task, but in how they are financed.

Public health insurance

  • Pay-as-you-go: Each year's contributions pay for the same year's costs. There are no reserves for old age.
  • Contribution based on income: a percentage of your salary, up to the contribution ceiling.
  • Family: Children and partners without their own income are insured free of charge.
  • Benefits: set by law (Social Code Book V) and the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA). The legislator can change them, including cutting them.
  • Supervision: Federal Office for Social Security and the federal states.

Private health insurance

  • Funded system: Every insured person builds up an ageing reserve that covers the higher costs in old age.
  • Premium based on entry age, health and tariff: independent of income.
  • Family: Each person has their own contract and their own premium.
  • Benefits: promised for life in the contract. The insurer may not cut them unilaterally.
  • Supervision: BaFin. Every premium adjustment must be checked and approved by an independent trustee.

The roots are older than Bismarck

  1. from the 12th centuryGuild brotherhoods

    Craftsmen pay into shared funds and support the sick and injured. Later the funds of masters and journeymen separate, an early forerunner of today's two systems.

  2. 1848The first private health insurance

    Officials of the Berlin police headquarters found their own health insurance. Further private insurers for civil servants, employees and the self-employed emerge in this period.

  3. 1883Bismarck's Health Insurance Act

    Compulsory insurance for workers begins. It builds on the existing local, company, guild and miners' funds and initially covers around 10 % of the population.

  4. 1996 to 2000Reform of private health insurance

    An independent expert commission investigates why premiums of older privately insured people rose sharply. Since 2000 new customers pay the statutory 10 % surcharge, which stabilises premiums in old age.

  5. 2009Compulsory insurance for everyone

    Everyone living in Germany must have health insurance, public or private. If you switch private insurer, you can take part of your ageing reserve with you.

What you get: the benefits

People argue a lot about premiums and hardly at all about benefits. Yet benefits are the real reason for the decision. First of all: German public health insurance is very good by international standards, with one of the most comprehensive benefit catalogues in the world. But by law it is solid basic care. Its benefits must be “sufficient, appropriate and economical” and may “not exceed what is necessary” (section 12 Social Code Book V). Good private comprehensive insurance goes further, promised by contract for life.

Good to know if you are new to Germany

There is no maximum sum. Neither public nor private.

In many countries health insurance only pays up to a fixed sum per year or per lifetime, after that you pay yourself. Not in Germany. Public insurance and private comprehensive insurance also cover very expensive treatment without an upper limit: cancer therapy, an organ transplant or modern antibody drugs where a single dose can cost several thousand euros. In private insurance a tariff can only limit individual benefits, for example dentures in the first years. We look out for this when choosing.

BenefitsPublicPrivate, good tariff
Specialist appointmentsoften weeks or months of waitingusually within days
Choice of doctordoctors with a public insurance licencefree choice, including private doctors and private clinics
Hospitaltreatment by the doctor on duty, shared roomsenior consultant or specialist of your choice, single or double room
New treatment methodsoutpatient only once approved by the Federal Joint Committeewhat is medically necessary, including new methods that are similarly promising
Medicinesco-payment of €5 to €10, often the product the insurer has a discount contract for, over-the-counter drugs for adults usually notno co-payment, the prescribed medicine, depending on the tariff also over-the-counter drugs
Denturesfixed subsidy of 60 % of standard care, up to 75 % with a bonus bookletusually 70 to 90 %, including implants and inlays
Glasses and contact lensesfor adults only with severe visual impairmentregular allowance, depending on the tariff also laser eye surgery
Medical aidsfixed amounts, standard versionhigher quality, for example hearing aids
AbroadEU and agreement countries, otherwise only limitedusually worldwide for travel and temporary stays
Co-paymentsfor example €10 per day in hospitalnone, apart from an agreed deductible
Benefit guaranteethe legislator can change and cut benefitsguaranteed for life in the contract

Simplified overview. Private benefits depend on the tariff, public insurance has exceptions, for example for hardship cases and chronic illnesses. An example of cuts: in 2004 the legislator largely removed glasses for adults from the benefits, and since 2005 there have only been fixed subsidies for dentures.

And something that is often overlooked: no health insurance simply pays for everything, neither public nor private. Public insurance pays what is in its benefit catalogue and medically necessary. Private insurance pays what is medically necessary and provided for in your contract. If a benefit is not included there, the insurer may and must refuse it, because it manages the money of all insured people. This is fairly regulated in both systems, and in both you can have a refusal reviewed. That is exactly what we are there for as brokers: we are glad to help if there is ever a dispute.

What makes the difference when it matters

  • Speed. With a serious diagnosis every week counts. Privately insured people often get specialist appointments, examinations and procedures within a few days.
  • Access. You can turn to specialists and university hospitals that are not tied to a public insurance licence.
  • Scope. Complex diagnostics, for example genetic tests, are covered if they make medical sense.

What to look out for

  • Not all tariffs are equal. Cheap entry-level tariffs can fall below public benefits in individual areas, such as psychotherapy or medical aids.
  • Health check: pre-existing conditions can lead to surcharges or a refusal.
  • Paying first: you often pay bills yourself first and then submit them.

Can I choose at all?

How do you work in Germany?

Your gross annual salary, expected

What does it cost you today?

Public contributions can be calculated exactly. Private premiums depend on age, health and tariff. So enter your personal quote, the fields only contain example values. What you see is what you pay yourself, after your employer's contribution.

Enter private premiums including compulsory long-term care insurance. Public calculated with 14.6 % plus the average additional contribution of 2.9 % and long-term care insurance for 2026.

Outlook over 20 years with the average increases from 2005 to 2025: public 4.0 %, private 3.1 % a year. An assumption, not a forecast. Salary, children and tariff change in real life.

How have premiums risen so far?

Both systems get more expensive because health care gets more expensive. From 2005 to 2025 the premium per fully insured person in private health insurance rose by 3.1 % a year on average, in public insurance by 4.0 %. Over 20 years that makes a clear difference.

2005 = 100. Average annual increase per fully insured person, therefore shown as a smooth line. Source: German Association of Actuaries (DAV), Aktuar Aktuell 68 (December 2024).

The ageing myth

“Private insurance becomes unaffordable in old age.” Almost everyone hears this sentence. It has a true core from the 1970s to 1990s. It has little to do with today's tariffs.

Average monthly premium of a man for private comprehensive insurance. The new customer in 1993 also paid almost seven times as much as in 1970, that is general cost inflation. The customer from 1970 paid considerably more again: plus 928 % in 23 years, 10.6 % a year on average. Source: report of the Independent Expert Commission of 1996, Bundestag printed paper 13/4945. Amounts in Deutsche Mark, not adjusted for inflation.

What went wrong back then

  • Ageing reserves already existed. Private health insurance had been run like life insurance for decades.
  • But they were calculated with a constant value of money. Inflation and rising treatment costs were not planned for. Every cost increase had to be financed later through premium increases, and these were particularly steep for older people.
  • People lived longer than calculated. New life tables increased premiums further.
  • The way back to public insurance was largely closed. “Once private, always private”, as the commission put it.

What has changed since

  • Statutory 10 % surcharge from age 21 to 60, since 2000. It is used from 65 to offset increases and from 80 to reduce the premium.
  • From 60 the surcharge ends, and the premium even falls slightly.
  • Premium relief tariffs reduce the premium from 67 by a fixed amount, a kind of pension insurance within health insurance.
  • Surplus interest largely goes towards stabilising premiums for older insured people.
  • Standard and basic tariff as a safety net if the premium becomes too high in old age.

Why premiums still rise

Not because of your age, but for reasons that affect publicly and privately insured people alike:

Medical progressNew medicines, diagnostic and surgical procedures save lives and cost money.
Wages in health careDuring the pandemic we applauded nurses, and today they rightly earn more. In the end the insured pay for it, public and private alike.
Hospital costsThe biggest cost driver. In private health insurance hospital benefits rose by 13.5 % in 2023.
We live longerGood for us, more expensive for insurance: more years in which treatment is needed.

Private premiums may only be adjusted if benefit spending deviates from the calculation by more than 10 % (5 % in many tariffs) or mortality by more than 5 %, and only with the approval of an independent trustee (section 203 Insurance Contract Act, section 155 Insurance Supervision Act). That is why increases often come in jumps.

Our recommendation

Our conclusion

If you earn well and are healthy, you should seriously consider private health insurance.

For a young, healthy professional with a salary well above the compulsory insurance threshold, private comprehensive insurance is the better choice in most cases: financially and above all in benefits, which are promised by contract for life. What matters is a strong tariff, a premium relief tariff for retirement and an insurer with a solid premium history.

Public insurance is usually better if several family members without their own income would need to be insured, if there are serious pre-existing conditions or if you will foreseeably earn considerably less, for example by working part-time.

Get a personal comparison →

Questions international professionals often ask us

I am coming with a Blue Card and earn above the threshold. When do I have to decide?

Ideally before your first working day. If you start your first job in Germany with a salary above the compulsory insurance threshold, you are exempt from the start. You can then take out private insurance straight away or join a public insurer voluntarily within three months. This decision shapes the next decades, so take your time beforehand.

Is my insurance from my home country recognised?

As a rule, no. For your residence permit and your employer you need health insurance that meets German requirements, i.e. a public insurer or private comprehensive insurance with a German insurer.

What happens if I leave Germany?

Public membership ends when you move away, there are no accrued entitlements. With private insurance you can suspend the contract for a small premium, known as an Anwartschaft. When you come back, your contract continues without a new health check, depending on the type even with your original entry age.

And if I earn less later?

If your salary as an employee falls below the compulsory insurance threshold, you become subject to public insurance again, but only until your 55th birthday. Within three months you can apply for exemption and stay private. From 55, those who were privately insured generally remain so. So plan the decision with your whole working life in mind.

Does my employer also pay half if I am privately insured?

Yes, they pay a contribution of half your premium, at most as much as they would pay for public insurance. In 2026 that is up to €508.59 for health insurance and €104.63 for long-term care insurance per month.